Joe Giltner at Five Canyons Park with a thank-you message to Area 4

A CAMPAIGN TO REMEMBER:

Campaign reflection, page 1 of 3Campaign reflection, page 2 of 3Campaign reflection, page 3 of 3

EMAIL TO DIRECTOR HODGES:

SUBJECT: Congratulations on Your Reelection, Director Hodges
1 message
From: JOE GILTNER <joe@joegiltner.com>
To: Paul Hodges <phodges06@aol.com>
Cc: Paul Hodges <Paul.Hodges@haywardrec.org>

Dear Director Hodges,

With the latest election results now reported, I wanted to congratulate you on your reelection to the H.A.R.D. Board of Directors. Although you never once introduced yourself, responded to my invitations to meet, or made any effort to have a conversation with me throughout this campaign, despite the fact that I am also one of your direct constituents, I figured at least one of us should extend that courtesy. So, congratulations.

I hope you reflect on what this election revealed. You entered this race with 19 years on the Board, four appointments, decades of political experience, longstanding relationships, establishment backing, and every advantage that comes with holding office. You had the name recognition, connections, resources, and, most importantly, time. I had just 53 days to build a campaign from scratch, reach thousands of residents, demonstrate my qualifications, earn voters' trust, and challenge Area 4's stagnant status quo, all while navigating the obstacles of a first-time candidate. Yet, despite those challenges, we built an incredible grassroots movement.

Then there was your ballot designation. Let's stop pretending that “INCUMBENT” was some innocent technicality. The election rules were clear, and after 19 years on the Board, you had more than enough experience to understand them. You used a ballot designation that violated the applicable election laws. We both understand why you did that and why that word matters. It conveys familiarity, legitimacy, and an advantage among voters who may know little else about the candidates. Given your experience, I find it difficult to accept that this was simply an innocent mistake.

You wanted every possible advantage in this election, and that designation gave you another one. Incumbency advantages are hardly a secret in political science, and it's difficult to take seriously the suggestion that someone with your experience didn't understand the significance of that designation. You already had nearly every advantage imaginable, yet you still used a designation that misled voters, violated election laws, and then shifted the blame elsewhere. In the end, you benefited from it. You got the advantage. And voters deserved better.

With nearly every advantage in your favor, this election should have been an easy landslide for you. Instead, more than 7,100 residents voted for a first-time candidate. Over 45% of voters chose someone other than you. I hope that gives you something to think about. Those weren't simply votes against you. They came from residents who listened, asked questions, and believed Area 4 deserved something different. I received more raw votes than President Sara Lamnin and Council Member George Syrop, with whom we shared many constituents in his District 1, and more than most candidates in district-based City Council and school board races across our county. In just 53 days, we built a wave of community support few saw coming. I encourage you not to dismiss those voters simply because you won.

And frankly, I hope you start communicating with the people you represent. I found it astonishing that your own daughters publicly suggested you didn't even need to speak with residents during this election. Imagine telling voters that their elected representative doesn't need to engage with them, answer their questions, or explain what he intends to accomplish. I don't know how anyone could consider that acceptable, much less defend it. Public service is not a lifetime entitlement, and winning an election does not excuse someone from having to communicate with the public.

I also want to address the behavior of some of your supporters and family members during this campaign. The personal attacks, attempts to discredit my character, hostile comments, and efforts to dig up anything that could be used against me were disturbing. I was a first-time candidate trying to give back to the community that raised me, and somehow that became an invitation for people, many decades older than me, to engage in behavior I would expect from schoolyard bullies. Several of those individuals owe me an apology. The experience was hurtful, exhausting, and unnecessary. Through all of it, you remained silent. Frankly, that silence only reinforced my disappointment in your leadership.

From the theft of my lawn signs and banners to the personal attacks, defamatory accusations, and repeated attempts to silence our movement, undermine my campaign, and keep residents unaware of this election, the image of Paul Hodges that your supporters worked so hard to portray now feels like a facade compared with what I experienced throughout this campaign. Growing up, I was taught that real leaders stand up against bullying rather than remain silent while it happens. You were a schoolteacher, someone who spent years working with young people and presumably teaching those same values. Of all people, I expected you to understand that. I expected better from you.

What makes this even more disappointing is that, despite everything, I made an effort to meet you. I reached out because I wanted to hear your perspective, understand your experience, and have a respectful conversation about Area 4's future. You never gave me that opportunity. Not once did you say hello, introduce yourself, or make an effort to get to know a resident whom you directly represented. After 19 years on the Board, I expected more professionalism and courtesy. Apparently, that was asking too much.

Nevertheless, I am incredibly proud of what we accomplished. In just 53 days, with no established political network, no campaign consultants, and no years of preparation, we managed to get thousands of residents interested in a parks and recreation district election. Who would have thought? People who had never paid attention to H.A.R.D. were suddenly asking about budgets, delayed projects, accountability, and what their elected representatives actually do. Whatever the final results show, that engagement is something I will always be proud of.

And I hope you understand that those residents are not going anywhere. They will be watching Board meetings, asking questions, examining public spending, and expecting answers. The days of assuming that nobody is paying attention to a parks and recreation district election may be coming to an end. I sincerely hope you embrace that rather than resent it.

After nearly two decades on the Board, I also hope you find the willingness to question the status quo instead of simply defending it. Experience should come with perspective, humility, and a willingness to recognize when things need to change. Just because something has been done the same way for years doesn't mean it should continue that way for another four.

And since we never had the opportunity to hear much from you during the campaign, perhaps you could finally tell residents what you actually intend to accomplish over the next four years. What is your vision for Area 4? What projects are you going to prioritize? What changes do you believe are necessary? What should residents expect from your next term of representation? These are fairly basic questions for someone seeking public office, yet, in your case, they remain largely unanswered. At this point, your priorities seem to be a closely guarded secret, beyond vague statements about safety and inclusivity in our parks. After 19 years on the Board, residents should not still be left wondering what you intend to accomplish, sir.

Despite everything, I genuinely wish you and your family good health, happiness, and peace. I understand that your family is going through a difficult time, and I would not wish that on anyone. I hope you enjoy the years ahead, find fulfillment in your personal life, and accomplish whatever you have set out to do, whatever that may be. As I told your family, I did not enter this race for personal attention or recognition, despite what some of your supporters have repeatedly suggested.

I genuinely care about my home, and I am already incredibly blessed in my own life. I have a beautiful family, amazing and supportive friends, an extremely fulfilling career, financial independence, my youthfulness and good health, and the opportunity to make a positive difference wherever life takes me. I have so much to be grateful for, and I did not need a seat on the H.A.R.D. Board to feel accomplished or fulfilled. I ran because I wanted to give something back to the community that gave me so much. I hope you recognize that the people who voted against you are still your constituents, and they deserve exactly the same attention and respect as those who supported you.

So congratulations again, Director Hodges. Although you've won this election, please don't mistake that victory for proof that residents are satisfied with your representation, your lack of communication, or the disconnect they've experienced from their appointed representative. Despite every advantage you held and the attempts I experienced to silence and bury my campaign, over 45% of voters still chose a different vision for Area 4. That should tell you something.

Area 4 deserves better communication, greater accountability, and representation that extends beyond simply holding a seat on the Board. I hope you'll prove over the next four years that you've heard that message.

Sincerely,

Joe Giltner
Joe Giltner for H.A.R.D. Director, Area 4 2026

Joe Giltner circular JG emblem

THANK YOU LETTER TO AREA 4:

Joe Giltner campaign emblem
November 3, 2026

HI AREA 4,

Thank you. Thank you for every vote, every view, every message, every text, every share, every email, every conversation, and every read. Thank you to every person who stopped to talk with me, challenged me, encouraged me, offered input, volunteered, donated, put up a sign, opened their home, or simply gave this campaign a chance. Thank you to every vendor who helped us produce what we needed, every printer who printed our literature, and every press that helped turn our ideas into the materials you saw throughout Area 4.

What we built together in just 53 days still amazes me, and I remain so humbled by it. I hope you could see and feel the love, energy, passion, and respect in everything we created, from our logo and lawn signs to our literature, banners, events, and emails. Every detail, large or small, was intentional and designed to reflect how deeply we care about our parks, our neighborhoods, our families, our seniors, and the community we all call home. This campaign was never some giant political operation. It was you, me, Area 4, and our community.

And before I ever filed, there were the people who pushed me to believe I could actually do this, especially the person who first told me I should run. You know who you are. 😉 My community, my family, my friends, and the incredible mentors who were there from that August 6 decision onward. You listened when I questioned whether I should run, let me vent, let me cry, challenged me when I needed it, reminded me why this mattered, and stood beside me through every high and every low that followed. You all know exactly who you are. I love you more than I can put into words, and I will never be able to thank you enough for helping me find the courage to take that first step.

I am honored that, with less than a day to make that decision, I WAS THE LAST CANDIDATE IN ALAMEDA COUNTY TO QUALIFY FOR THE ALAMEDA COUNTY BALLOT.

From the day I filed, I knew what kind of race I was walking into. I had less than 24 hours to decide whether to put my name on the ballot, and I was reluctant because I knew how much time, energy, emotional toll, financial sacrifice, and commitment running a campaign would require. But the more I looked at the record of our appointed representative, the more convinced I became that Area 4 deserved better. If I did not step forward, our appointed director would have automatically been appointed to another four-year term.

To this day, he still has not offered meaningful responses to many of the questions residents asked. He avoided residents throughout the election and acted entitled to another four years without ever having to answer directly to the people he represented. And when I tried to hold our appointed director accountable, I was called disrespectful and even a “mosquito.”

At the same time, many of my non-resident critics and those within the establishment simply told residents to vote for our long-serving appointed representative, but rarely explained why they believed he had earned another four years, what his plans were, or what vision he had for Area 4 over the next four years. My opponent rarely spoke for himself throughout this election. Instead, others repeatedly spoke on his behalf while simultaneously insisting they were not his “spokesperson.”

On top of all of that, when we officially launched, we knew that going up against a 19-year, three-time appointed director who falsified “INCUMBENT” on his ballot was going to be an uphill battle from day one. We also knew we were not just running against one opponent, but against an establishment with a network of staff, employees, organizations, and longstanding political relationships. We were starting from scratch, without political endorsements and, in many cases, without even being invited into the rooms where those endorsements were being considered.

We had only weeks to introduce ourselves, build an entire campaign from nothing, earn the trust of residents, persuade as many groups and organizations as possible to give us a chance to speak, and try to give Area 4 as fair a choice as we could. In all honesty, the establishment made sure nearly everything was stacked against us.

FROM THE MOMENT WE FILED, WE WERE THE UNDERDOGS. AND EVEN NOW, WE STILL ARE.

Despite all the challenges we had to overcome just to get this campaign off the ground, somewhere along the way, this race became very different from what people expected. What journalists, political commentators, and critics covering the election initially predicted would be an easy blowout victory for my opponent, with a first-time candidate like me having little chance of making the race competitive, instead became a race they are now describing as a "nail-biter" and one of the final races worth watching as votes continue to be counted and the outcome remains close. Whatever the final count shows, the fact that a campaign built from nothing in only 53 days could make this race competitive says something powerful about what can happen when residents decide that long-standing political establishments and out-of-touch representation deserve to be challenged.

As the race became more competitive, what I thought would primarily be a campaign about policy also became far more personal than I ever expected. For weeks, I endured constant personal attacks, rude comments, unprovoked and biased accusations, misinformation, campaign materials and eight-foot vinyl banners being stolen, damage to my property including slashed tires, and blatant racism directed at me and my communities of color. There were also people spreading unwarranted lies and false information about me who had never met me, never had a conversation with me, and in many cases did not even live in Area 4.

That part of this campaign was deeply disappointing. I never expected that simply putting my name on a ballot and asking questions about our parks, public spending, representation, and accountability would require enduring that level of hostility for weeks.

But we rose above it. We defended ourselves when we had to. We fought back against the hate, refused to be intimidated, and kept bringing the conversation back to Area 4, our residents, our parks, and the issues that caused me to run in the first place.

And that was why we kept going. We ran anyway. We built anyway. We asked the questions anyway. With each passing day, more people began paying attention to an election and a District that many residents had never thought much about before.

THERE WAS NO SECRET POLITICAL MACHINE. I AM NOT A POLITICIAN.

There was me. There were our neighbors, community leaders, residents, friends, volunteers, and supporters. There were people who believed Area 4 deserved a choice and that there was nothing wrong with asking whether our community could expect more from its representation.

We built this together.

Area 4 gave me an opportunity I never expected, and you gave a first-time candidate a chance to be heard. You gave me the opportunity to ask questions that needed to be asked, put new ideas on the table, talk about representation, talk about our parks, talk about seniors, talk about public money, and remind people that their voices mattered in what happened here.

And together, in 53 days, we did it all. We built the campaign. We told our story. We asked the questions. We stood our ground. We gave Area 4 a choice.

That meant more to me than I can adequately put into words. There were no years of planning behind this. There was no giant organization waiting to launch. We took what we had, believed in what Area 4 could become, and built something together in 53 days. There was so much more I wanted to do and so much more we had planned, but between responding to FPPC and Secretary of State matters, dealing with dirty politics, and simply running out of time, we could not get to everything. Fifty-three days disappeared faster than I ever imagined.

And maybe that is the part of this experience I most want other residents to remember. If you have ever looked at your city, your district, your neighborhood, or your local government and thought, someone should step up, maybe that someone is you.

If you are thinking about running for office because you believe your community needs a different voice, call me. I am serious. I will sit down with you, tell you everything I learned, show you what worked, tell you what did not, and help you build your campaign from the ground up.

Look at what we built in 53 days, starting with nothing. Imagine what we could have built with three months, six months, or a year, the time most candidates have to prepare.

That may be one of the biggest lessons I took away from this experience. More people should run. More residents should step forward. Leadership should not belong only to the same people who have held office for years or decades. If you believe your community deserves another choice, put your name on the ballot. Someone may already be waiting for you to do it.

NO MATTER WHAT, WE DID THIS TOGETHER.

Whatever happens when every vote is counted, I have so much to be thankful for. I will never forget these 53 days, the people I met, the stories you shared with me, the lessons I learned, the support I felt, or the opportunity this community gave me.

When you look back at this campaign, I hope you remember that it came from a genuine love for the place we call home. I hope you saw that in every email, every proposal, every event, every question, every sign, and every conversation. Most of all, I hope we proved that you do not need a political machine to step forward. Sometimes, you just need a community, an idea, and the willingness to try.

And this is not the last you will see of me. We are not done yet. There is still more to build, more to ask, more to learn, and more to do for the place we call home.

But until then, thank you, Area 4.

So, for one last time as your candidate running for H.A.R.D. Director, Area 4, thank you.

Eternally blessed, deeply grateful, and humbled,
JOSEPH "JOE" GILTNER
Candidate for H.A.R.D. Director, Area 4 2026

THIS IS ONLY THE BEGINNING:

The campaign may be coming to a close, but my commitment to Area 4 is not. I want to hear from you. Let's keep the conversation going and continue building our community together.